Yes We Can
Adolescent
bullying is certainly nothing new and neither is homosexuality, which is why
the recent trend of queer youths committing suicide is so troubling. It’s become such a problem many are
pushing for anti-bullying laws.
It’s not just the bullying that hurts queer youth, it’s also religious
rejection. Many queer teens are
brought up in household where it is not acceptable to be gay. Queer youth need to know that they are
accepted and loved and have adults who support them. I
wish I could say evangelical Christians were becoming more accepting of
homosexuality, but that’s simply not true. Former presidential candidate Michelle Bauchmann’s husband
runs a “pray away the gay” clinic, and former presidential candidate Rick Perry
ran an extremely homophobic ad, luckily however its one of the most disliked
videos on YouTube.
Huffington
Post article “Religion, Family, and Gay Teen Suicide” author Aaron Anson tries
to understand the current situations.
Anson begins by talking about a teen who killed himself. The teen, Anson notes, was brought up
in a very religious and prejudicial family. Anson goes further, “This appears to be a common thread among every gay suicide I've had to
ponder. Deep in the fabric of the pain that pushes them to take their own lives
is hate, more than likely
"justified" by the misguided religious
beliefs of others. Most media attention tends to focus on peer bullying as a
major factor, and I agree with that to an extent. But often overlooked is the
impact of the hateful bullying that takes place right in our own homes.” If a teen is bullied at school and then
rejected at home, where can they turn to be loved and supported? Anson firmly
believes that “Healing has to begin in our homes.”
As
bleak as the religious front may seem, there is hope. A survey conducted by Pew Forum asked many denominations
whether homosexuality should be accepted by society, and the majority of
denominations overwhelmingly agreed.
Mainline churches agreed at 56 percent, Catholics with 58 percent, other
Christians at 69 percent, Jews with 79 percent, Buddhists at 82 percent, other
faiths with 84 percent, and unaffiliated at 71. Not only that but the Episcopalian Church was the first to
appoint openly gay priest Gene Robinson as a Bishop. Also in a seminar “American Catholics in the Twenty-First
Century” professor and practicing Catholic Michele Dillon stated that while the
older generation in the church is not accepting of homosexuality, the majority
of young members are very accepting of homosexuality and this will soon change
the Catholic perception of homosexuality as a sin.
Many
queer youth struggle with their home lives and often find themselves targets of
bullying for being gay or even appearing gay. In her article “Bullying, Harassment, and Violence Among
Students” Nan Stein points out that while there is “zero tolerance” in schools
this does not include gender based bullying. She writes, “Sexual or gender harassment rarely show up in
any of the standard analyses of school violence. Gender is missing.” Gender and sexuality are absolutely
missing from protecting teens against bullying. Instead of zero tolerance Stein suggests “zero
indifference.” While her ideas are great some would be hard to implement, but
schools should absolutely train staff on the issues of gender bullying, provide
compassionate responses and counseling to the harasser and victim, and treat
gender bullying in the same way as bullying.
John
D’emilio discusses the hardships of coming out and even just being gay in a
heterosexist society in his article “Homosexuality and American Society: An
Overview.”
He writes, “’Coming out’ – recognizing one’s homosexual
desires, subsequently attempting to act upon them… was a lonely, difficult, and
sometimes excruciatingly painful experience… Lesbians and homosexuals grew up
with the male/female couple as their only model of intimate erotic
relationships.” While it’s true
our society is heterosexist for the most part, many celebrities are coming out
and several very popular shows feature loving and erotic homosexual
relationships.
While
its nearly impossible to change society overnight. We can create a society that is more accepting and
understanding through better sex education, more comprehensive anti-bullying
measure, churches becoming more accepting, and mainstream media as more gay
friendly. We can stop this queer
teen suicide epidemic.
Works Citied
1.) Anson, Aaron. "Religion,
Family, and Gay Teen Suicide." The
Huffington Post. 17 Jan. 2012. Web.
<http://www.huffingtonpost.com/aaron-anson/gay-teen-suicide_b_1204852.html>.
2.) "Comparative Religions -
U.S. Religious Landscape Study - Pew Forum on Religion & Public Life." Religion in American Culture -- Pew
Forum on Religion & Public Life. Web.
09 Feb. 2012. <http://religions.pewforum.org/comparisons>.
3.) D'emilio, John.
"Homosexuality and American Society: An Overview." Sexual Politics, Sexual,
Communities in the United States 1940-1970 (1983). Print.
4.) Dilion, Michele. "American
Catholics in the Twenty-First Century." American Catholics in the
Twenty-First Century. First Presbyterian Church, Santa Barbara. 19 Jan. 2012.
Lecture.
5.) Stein, Nan. "Bullying,
Harassment and Violence among Students." Radical
Teacher 80 (2007). Print.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteAlthough queer youth have always been the target of bullying and harassment, I definitely agree that our heterosexist society can change for the better. When you mentioned the results of a survey regarding the attitudes of religious denominations towards society's acceptance of homosexuals, I thought that the statistics were quite startling...For instance, “mainline churches agreed [that homosexuals should be integrated within society] by 58%, and Catholics agreed by 56%...” I would have never expected such a significant amount of Catholics to be pro-LGBTQ, because I've always thought that Catholics generally tend to uphold tradition and oppose deviation. These statistics remind me of an article written by Mary L. Gray, regarding the ways that queer youth living in rural areas can establish their identities. In one of her case studies, Gray writes about a group of queer youth living in Springhaven, Kentucky. As a hobby and a rite of passage, these boys would go to Walmart, dress up in drag, and strut up and down the aisles for their “runway show.” I was quite surprised that the manager of Walmart allowed them to make such an explicit display of their identity...and this event didn't occur just anywhere...it occurred in Kentucky, a rural, backwater area that was “...frozen in time by local defiance of change” (Gray 52), which surprised me even further. Therefore, I agree with you that our society is slowly but surely developing more tolerance towards the gay community.
ReplyDelete"Comparative Religions - U.S. Religious Landscape Study - Pew Forum on Religion & Public Life." Religion in American Culture -- Pew Forum on Religion & Public Life. Web. 09 Feb. 2012. .
Gray, Mary L. "From Websites to Walmart: Youth, Identity Work, and the Queering of Boundary Publics in Small Town, USA." American Studies Summer 2007 48 (2007): 49-59. JSTOR. 16 Feb. 2012 .
I agree that religion plays an integral role in the shaping of Queer youth’s lives. Some of the pressure lies in the Holy Texts of each respective religion, but most of the pressure comes from the individual members of the organization. Personally, I have experienced the anxiety and self-awareness of living in a religious household while having the intersecting identity of being Queer. The older individuals of my church are adamantly opposed to the idea of same-sex relations but my generation is much more accepting and seeks to understand rather than to judge. I look forward to the day when my sexual identity can coexist peacefully with all aspects and members of my religion. Martin Manalansan exemplifies the start of this relationship in his article, “Searching for Community.” He tells how the Filipino gay community in Manhattan combined Santacruzan, a Catholic celebration, with different aspects of the LGBTQ community - fashion shows, BDSM, and the ever famous six pack - to create a new subculture. Such communities as this lead me to believe that one day, my religion and sexuality can be expressed without any sense of anxiety or fear of excommunication; that one day, all queer teens will be able to integrate different aspects of themselves simultaneously and fearlessly; that one day, all individuals with all intersections will be able to be who they were born to be - and not feel that being themselves is incorrect in any way.
ReplyDeleteManalasan, Martin IV. “Searching for Community: Filipino Gay Men from New York City”. GLQ:
A Journal of Lesbian and Gay Studies. Routeledge Chapman Hall, 1993.